The discussion group… where no discussion is tolerated

I was recently made aware of a little fracas on one of the various FaceBook Boer War ‘discussion’ sites. It would seem the problem, however, was that someone had dared to discuss a few of the more cherished Holy Cows of Boer War myth:

I have never met any of the gentlemen involved, but, as you can see, this chap has been excommunicated, seemingly for the unpardonable sins of:

1) pointing out that the invading Boers looted and pillaged their way through Natal – though completely true, this does not fit with the reinvention of them as the innocent victims of the piece

2) daring to state that the war started because the Boers invaded British territory – see above

3) presumably refuting the usual, self-serving, old bollocks of the British army ‘massing on the borders’ – in reality, no British troops were ‘massed on the borders’, but it is the sort of thing certain idiots like to claim in a desperate attempt to justify the Boer attacks

4) pointing out that the side which declares war, attacks and invades the other, is traditionally considered to be the aggressor – again, daring to bring up the inconvenient reality that the Boers started the war is not the done thing, at least according to Defenders of the Myth™

It would seem that even those who swear by them, are beginning to fear that their much-treasured myths simply cannot stand any sort of scrutiny, and therefore, in truly Orwellian fashion, no such discussion will be tolerated on this discussion group. Indeed, the True Believers™ have clearly realised their preferred version can only be kept limping along a bit longer by frantically ‘cancelling’ anyone who dares to point out that the Emperor is not wearing any clothes.

What a truly bizarre way to ‘study’ history.


  • Douglas Mason Posted October 18, 2021 7:19 am

    Cancel the cancel culture

  • Trevor blanche Posted October 18, 2021 3:33 pm

    Totally agree. I was also banned for pointing out that it was harsh censorship.. my first comment on the site.

  • Trevor Posted October 18, 2021 4:35 pm

    I too was banned for saying mr. Scottie banning was harsh.. my first and what seems my last comment on that site.

  • Anthony Scott aka Scottie Posted July 13, 2022 9:22 am

    I am a Bit late to the party on commenting on this one Guys, it’s worth noting that the censorship included at least 5 British Forum Members who were friends on my FB list where deleted from the site lol….

    It’s also worth noting that my ‘deleting’ from the Forum was explained on the open forum by the site owner, who I had supported fully since he created it and regarded as an on line friend, that I had abused a Moderator via messenger which was a complete misrepresentation of events. The site owner also deleted me as a ‘Friend’ on FB as they all closed ranks. Anyway thanks for highlighting it Chris. regards Scottie

    • Bulldog Posted July 13, 2022 10:38 am

      Wear your ‘cancelling’ as a badge of honour, Mr Scott! Clearly you were pointing out things which they couldn’t refute and the only way they could maintain their embarrassing fiction a little longer was to get rid of you. I’m really not sure if I should find them funny, or pathetic – maybe both?

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *